By By Sudarshan Sharma
It is a perilous time to be an immigrant in America, and infinitely more difficult if you carry a refugee background. Today, a sprawling right-wing media apparatus serves as the primary engine for the MAGA movement, a machinery that demands a constant infusion of anti-immigrant rhetoric to survive. This ecosystem is largely indifferent to facts; its vital energy is derived from hostility toward marginalized groups, people of color, and the very immigrants who strive to build lives here. To this base, immigrants are the perpetual, convenient cause of America’s economic and social downturns.
With pivotal elections always on the horizon, political strategists are perpetually searching for lightning rods to charge their base. When foreign policy crises fail to ignite the necessary fervor, immigrants remain the most dependable, reliable punching bags. Past calculated narratives, such as the weaponization of ICE deportations or the sensationalized allegations surrounding Somali daycare centers, offered just enough fuel to keep resentment simmering. Seeking a fresh target, far-right outlets like The Daily Wire worked overnight to construct a new villain.
The Bhutanese-American refugee community fit their desired profile perfectly: situated in a critical swing state, carrying a refugee status that right-wing commentators frequently denigrate, and possessing an older population naturally reliant on state healthcare benefits. The raw ingredients were there to distort.
A genuine journalistic piece requires data to support its thesis, but if numbers are sufficiently isolated, they become incredibly easy to twist. Because this narrative did not need to sell itself on merit alone, its publication required precise political timing. That synchronization was not difficult to achieve, given that partisan journalists and lawmakers were motivated by the exact same outcome: an anti-immigrant spectacle, a political witch-hunt, and a damning, pre-determined narrative.
The resulting “Medicaid Millionaire” report is not journalism; it is pure propaganda. The data is so heavily skewed that it completely loses its original context. For example, the headline-grabbing 81% statistic might have reflected reality a decade ago when families were first being resettled and required temporary transitional assistance. The report’s claim that 19% of the community owns healthcare businesses appears to be a rudimentary, fabricated math equation: subtracting 81 from 100.
Similarly, the claim that a single home healthcare agency received $134 million in Medicaid funds intentionally obscures the truth. That figure represents a cumulative gross payment over a ten-year period, averaging roughly $13.4 million annually. The reporter deliberately ignores the massive overhead, wages, and operating expenses the company paid out. Whether the business turned a profit was irrelevant to the author; the singular objective was to magnify the number to manufacture the illusion of systemic corruption.
The report even names some individuals accused of executing multi-million dollar fraud through home healthcare businesses who, in reality, do not own any entities that bill Medicaid. Furthermore, the report flags a $1.2 million federal grant awarded to the Bhutanese Community of Central Ohio (BCCO), omitting that this funding was spread across 12 years. BCCO received and utilized these grants exactly as any other registered non-profit does by delivering vital services and maintaining strict compliance with transparency reports required by funders.
One does not need to be a rocket scientist to analyze the flaws in this paper, its skewed data, or its weak arguments. Even the baseline language utilized in the article lacks standard journalistic decency. But accuracy was never the point. The goal was to inflame anti-immigrant rhetoric, incite public fear, and fracture community solidarity.
During such turbulent times, one would traditionally expect elected officials to stand up, offer a message of solidarity, or at least reach out to ask how the community is faring. Thus far, there has been a resounding silence. The very liberal and progressive local leaders who routinely champion the values, economic contributions, and cultural fabric that immigrants and refugees bring to Ohio have vanished. It appears those grand statements are reserved exclusively for convenient times and for election cycles when these same leaders rely heavily on our community’s votes. This is the stark reality of being an immigrant, and specifically a refugee, in modern America.
To be absolutely clear, there is no room for anyone who misuses government systems, abuses healthcare frameworks, or exploits legal loopholes to enrich themselves. We do not condone or support such actions under any circumstances, and anyone proven guilty of a crime must be held accountable under the law. However, we must demand a fair, just, and impartial application of the judicial system.
It is also critical to understand that home healthcare agencies operate under stringent state rules and regulations. It is the fundamental duty of the state to ensure proper vetting, oversight, and monitoring of these programs. If these alleged businesses were failing to meet state standards, why were they permitted to operate for years and receive state funds without intervention? If they were following state guidance as required, then they were not merely conducting business, they were serving a vulnerable population, providing vital care, creating local jobs, and contributing to the tax base.
In a standard industry scenario, a home healthcare agency spends roughly 90% to 97% of its revenue simply operating the business, retaining a narrow 3% to 10% profit margin. An agency bringing in $1 million a month requires an immense caseload of roughly 250 clients. At best, the owner might take home $30,000 to $100,000 monthly before taxes. Split among multiple business partners, that profit shrinks significantly, requiring decades of continuous operation to reach true wealth. Reaching a scale of 250 clients takes years of intense labor, and purchasing an agency of that magnitude requires millions of dollars in upfront capital investment.
But nuanced operational facts do not serve the creators of the “Medicaid Millionaire” myth. They are selling a narrative of bigotry wrapped in political convenience at the expense of a vulnerable population. Even if we accept that there are bad actors within the home healthcare sector, they represent isolated cases found across every demographic in the industry. This is not a “Bhutanese problem”, it is a standard regulatory and societal challenge that must be addressed through proper legal channels.
Punish the wrongdoer, not the entire community. This is a foundational human value. A civilized society can only function when it adheres to shared norms, due process, and equal treatment under the law, regardless of class or background. The current weaponized rhetoric deployed against law-abiding residents is a dangerous departure from democratic principles, representing a reckless approach to governance that threatens the safety of our entire community.
Support the New Americans magazine to continue to serve our community with precise news that affects the new American, immigrant and refugee community. https://paypal.com/donate/? Dr;/.hosted_button_id=8LHFS78NRNJJY&source=url
